Team Years Prince Fielder Cubs 6 David Ortiz Red Sox 2 Albert Pujols Cardinals 7 Jose Reyes Giants 5 Jimmy Rollins Phillies 5 Aramis Ramirez Marlins 4 Carlos Beltran White Sox 3 Coco Crisp Mets 4 Michael Cuddyer Rockies 4 Jason Kubel Athletics 1 Grady Sizemore Rays 1 Josh Willingham Blue Jays 3 Mark Buehrle Red Sox 3 Aaron Harang Diamondbacks 3 Rich Harden Blue Jays 1 Edwin Jackson Cardinals 3 Hiroki Kuroda Yankees 2 Javier Vazquez Marlins 1 CJ Wilson Yankees 5 Heath Bell Red Sox 3 Ryan Madson Blue Jays 3 Jonathan Papelbon Mets 4 Francisco Rodriguez Marlins 4 Jose Valverde Tigers 3